Church canons

Chalcedon: transfer and jurisdiction

What can an incomplete query establish?

What this scene lets you inspect

These recorded cases retain evaluation status alongside any logical support. If a result reports missing inputs or a type error, that limitation stays visible; positive support alone does not establish an unrestricted successful calculation.

A retained historical model, with concrete bearers and actions.

Read the source passages

Supplied facts → recorded answers

Each card is one query, including its step in a recorded case. Open the inputs to see exactly what was supplied.

truth · step 1 / 1

Fathers canons on transfer keep force (Cleric)

Case: CHL R01

Positive supportEvaluation: TYPE_ERROR

Provide For The Poor
Cleric · duty · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Supplied inputs & evaluation context

positive Clergy serving in another city (Cleric)
positive Member of (Cleric, Church)

decisionTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
knowledgeTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
legalTime: 0451-10-20
timezone: UTC

Apostolic Canons · Canon 41 Chalcedon · Canon 27 Chalcedon · Canon 21 Chalcedon · Canon 11

Inspect this answer and proof ↗

Computation identity

1 stated expectations verified · Expectations verified

Result: sha256:48961da468392239062d15509a86ca3b3b3164d10c4c8e56a30dbd6c056a15cb
Proof: sha256:133a420bf0e7e0b8cc7e6d5a952bdd257d1cc14ec093f2e553d16269f28f9233
Program: sha256:004d37dbfaeb7827e45e7e6686114881b0ef483cc75de8174c82cd6be742e40c
Producer: bbeee997a8ef11816d14fc7a3d2f7e3afb74ceed923c614dafeaf6d92dcc9275

truth · step 1 / 1

Fathers canons on transfer keep force (Cleric)

Case: CHL R02

No support derivedEvaluation: TYPE_ERROR

Provide For The Poor
Cleric · duty · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Supplied inputs & evaluation context

positive Member of (Cleric, Church)

decisionTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
knowledgeTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
legalTime: 0451-10-20
timezone: UTC

Apostolic Canons · Canon 41 Chalcedon · Canon 27 Chalcedon · Canon 21 Chalcedon · Canon 11

Inspect this answer and proof ↗

Computation identity

1 stated expectations verified · Expectations verified

Result: sha256:e03d937081c75aab52741920a774a263d14b995e10daf52a86418bbd51d9457b
Proof: sha256:356205e8a6b4c189604bac42a63afaaa76d8bfb735345ae7e99a1c6ae23d5ed0
Program: sha256:004d37dbfaeb7827e45e7e6686114881b0ef483cc75de8174c82cd6be742e40c
Producer: bbeee997a8ef11816d14fc7a3d2f7e3afb74ceed923c614dafeaf6d92dcc9275

positions · step 1 / 1

Positions

Case: CHL R03

39 returned positionsEvaluation: TYPE_ERROR

Remain Outside Communion In Assembly
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Grant Church Property To Kin
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Provide For The Poor
Cleric · duty · ACTIVE

Grave Sin
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Deny Christ Under Fear
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Eat Unclean Meat
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Appropriate Church Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Dismiss Own Wife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Eat In Tavern
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Hold Civil Office
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Rebaptize
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Cleric Self Mutilation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Military And Ecclesiastical Power
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Slight Creation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Stand Security
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Strike Sinners
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Worldly Care
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Refuse Penitent
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Decline Share Without Reason
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Act Without Agreement Of All
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Publish Heretical Books
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Self Mutilation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Minor Order Dice And Drink
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Invoke Not Trinitarian
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Refuse Accepted Ministry
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Read Outside Canon
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Fast On Sabbath Or Sunday
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Church Power By Secular Rulers
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Fail To Supply Needy Cleric
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Neglect The Flock
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Single Witness
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Rent Others Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Ordain Without Proclamation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Seize The Deceased Bishops Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Broker Simony
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Disturb The Constantinopolitan Order
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Supplied inputs & evaluation context

positive Member of (Cleric, Church)
positive Cleric in the firm (Cleric)
positive Cleric lost homeland (Cleric)
positive Clergy serving in another city (Cleric)

decisionTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
knowledgeTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
legalTime: 0451-10-20
timezone: UTC

Inspect this answer and proof ↗

Computation identity

1 stated expectations verified · Expectations verified

Result: sha256:486a5fde0e114e9077256c64bf7f35dea1aef5a4d09c8a04927d9743e0dd86f7
Proof: sha256:e32a7e5d5dce78eb5f15ec3116e9462642252e7661531f09b004ff0509dc4e94
Program: sha256:004d37dbfaeb7827e45e7e6686114881b0ef483cc75de8174c82cd6be742e40c
Producer: bbeee997a8ef11816d14fc7a3d2f7e3afb74ceed923c614dafeaf6d92dcc9275

positions · step 1 / 1

Positions

Case: CHL R04

11 returned positionsEvaluation: TYPE_ERROR

Provide For The Poor
Reader · duty · ACTIVE

Provide For The Poor
Woman · duty · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Reader · prohibition · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Woman · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Reader · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Woman · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Reader · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Woman · prohibition · ACTIVE

Reader Marries Heretic
Reader · prohibition · VIOLATED

Supplied inputs & evaluation context

positive Reader allowed to marry (Reader)
positive Member of (Reader, Church)
positive Member of (Woman, Church)
positive Married heretic woman (Reader)
positive Promised conversion (Woman)

decisionTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
knowledgeTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
legalTime: 0451-10-20
timezone: UTC

Apostolic Canons · Canon 41 Chalcedon · Canon 27 Chalcedon · Canon 21 Chalcedon · Canon 11 Chalcedon · Canon 14

Inspect this answer and proof ↗

Computation identity

1 stated expectations verified · Expectations verified

Result: sha256:94f7b4f2c9e3bc69cd18599a353062df3eb3b33db041e8f702d92e47f39fc356
Proof: sha256:e4fdc3a980f42a69570e6b150c073d1f6b695188ad7d9d59451f4a44e690c60b
Program: sha256:004d37dbfaeb7827e45e7e6686114881b0ef483cc75de8174c82cd6be742e40c
Producer: bbeee997a8ef11816d14fc7a3d2f7e3afb74ceed923c614dafeaf6d92dcc9275

truth · step 1 / 1

Marriage permitted for promise (Woman)

Case: CHL R04a

Positive supportEvaluation: TYPE_ERROR

Provide For The Poor
Reader · duty · ACTIVE

Provide For The Poor
Woman · duty · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Reader · prohibition · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Woman · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Reader · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Woman · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Reader · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Woman · prohibition · ACTIVE

Reader Marries Heretic
Reader · prohibition · VIOLATED

Supplied inputs & evaluation context

positive Reader allowed to marry (Reader)
positive Member of (Reader, Church)
positive Member of (Woman, Church)
positive Married heretic woman (Reader)
positive Promised conversion (Woman)

decisionTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
knowledgeTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
legalTime: 0451-10-20
timezone: UTC

Apostolic Canons · Canon 41 Chalcedon · Canon 27 Chalcedon · Canon 21 Chalcedon · Canon 11 Chalcedon · Canon 14

Inspect this answer and proof ↗

Computation identity

1 stated expectations verified · Expectations verified

Result: sha256:b238abf446a4498880e338f52c2a47d9f8ee5ccde449b7b08a156fd8b2c9bd0d
Proof: sha256:171c65e7cabfb6227561b733e25dba4cd7ef6844ec2665773b3ce26d01932884
Program: sha256:004d37dbfaeb7827e45e7e6686114881b0ef483cc75de8174c82cd6be742e40c
Producer: bbeee997a8ef11816d14fc7a3d2f7e3afb74ceed923c614dafeaf6d92dcc9275

positions · step 1 / 1

Positions

Case: CHL R05

4 returned positionsEvaluation: TYPE_ERROR

Provide For The Poor
Cleric · duty · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Supplied inputs & evaluation context

positive Member of (Cleric, Church)
positive Held civil office (Cleric)

decisionTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
knowledgeTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
legalTime: 0451-10-20
timezone: UTC

Apostolic Canons · Canon 41 Chalcedon · Canon 27 Chalcedon · Canon 21 Chalcedon · Canon 11

Inspect this answer and proof ↗

Computation identity

1 stated expectations verified · Expectations verified

Result: sha256:d0ec41335b4f0515eb23371001204ae8772d4a7c3b9a4287f06e583214b84f9f
Proof: sha256:2c8d30a38337ff36e22c9959a0ef12885f8a8b3c3bda82dd5661b9b8c7696222
Program: sha256:004d37dbfaeb7827e45e7e6686114881b0ef483cc75de8174c82cd6be742e40c
Producer: bbeee997a8ef11816d14fc7a3d2f7e3afb74ceed923c614dafeaf6d92dcc9275

truth · step 1 / 1

Equal prerogative of new rome (Church)

Case: CHL R06

Positive supportEvaluation: TYPE_ERROR

Remain Outside Communion In Assembly
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Grant Church Property To Kin
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Provide For The Poor
Cleric · duty · ACTIVE

Grave Sin
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Deny Christ Under Fear
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Eat Unclean Meat
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Appropriate Church Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Dismiss Own Wife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Eat In Tavern
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Hold Civil Office
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Rebaptize
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Cleric Self Mutilation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Military And Ecclesiastical Power
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Slight Creation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Stand Security
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Strike Sinners
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Worldly Care
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Refuse Penitent
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Decline Share Without Reason
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Act Without Agreement Of All
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Publish Heretical Books
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Self Mutilation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Minor Order Dice And Drink
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Invoke Not Trinitarian
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Refuse Accepted Ministry
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Read Outside Canon
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Fast On Sabbath Or Sunday
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Church Power By Secular Rulers
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Fail To Supply Needy Cleric
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Neglect The Flock
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Single Witness
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Rent Others Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Ordain Without Proclamation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Seize The Deceased Bishops Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Broker Simony
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Disturb The Constantinopolitan Order
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Supplied inputs & evaluation context

positive Member of (Cleric, Church)
positive Cleric in the firm (Cleric)
positive New rome sees (Church)

decisionTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
knowledgeTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
legalTime: 0451-10-20
timezone: UTC

Inspect this answer and proof ↗

Computation identity

1 stated expectations verified · Expectations verified

Result: sha256:de1ef53e172c9a11a9965c16428fae87555d2722b382340f8cb1cf98c1099b80
Proof: sha256:0405463a7f8549b0edce68f24f326d68fde874dd34785450f8cbdae25d378233
Program: sha256:004d37dbfaeb7827e45e7e6686114881b0ef483cc75de8174c82cd6be742e40c
Producer: bbeee997a8ef11816d14fc7a3d2f7e3afb74ceed923c614dafeaf6d92dcc9275

truth · step 1 / 1

Equal prerogative of new rome (Church)

Case: CHL R07

No support derivedEvaluation: TYPE_ERROR

Remain Outside Communion In Assembly
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Grant Church Property To Kin
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Provide For The Poor
Cleric · duty · ACTIVE

Grave Sin
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Deny Christ Under Fear
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Eat Unclean Meat
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Appropriate Church Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Dismiss Own Wife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Eat In Tavern
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Hold Civil Office
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Rebaptize
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Cleric Self Mutilation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Military And Ecclesiastical Power
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Slight Creation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Stand Security
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Strike Sinners
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Worldly Care
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Refuse Penitent
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Decline Share Without Reason
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Act Without Agreement Of All
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Publish Heretical Books
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Self Mutilation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Minor Order Dice And Drink
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Invoke Not Trinitarian
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Refuse Accepted Ministry
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Read Outside Canon
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Fast On Sabbath Or Sunday
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Church Power By Secular Rulers
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Fail To Supply Needy Cleric
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Neglect The Flock
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Single Witness
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Abduct AWife
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Accept Accusation Without Examination
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Rent Others Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Give Commendatory Letters To Beggars
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Ordain Without Proclamation
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Seize The Deceased Bishops Property
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Broker Simony
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Disturb The Constantinopolitan Order
Cleric · prohibition · ACTIVE

Supplied inputs & evaluation context

positive Member of (Cleric, Church)
positive Cleric in the firm (Cleric)

decisionTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
knowledgeTime: 0451-10-20T12:00:00Z
legalTime: 0451-10-20
timezone: UTC

Inspect this answer and proof ↗

Computation identity

1 stated expectations verified · Expectations verified

Result: sha256:9bae5f7354e44bbefc6b5a11d2dc83f9f4765bb228b6676be44d0bb2b0644880
Proof: sha256:f0422bdf8462016d0343d61912b6fb8d73b135cc5808b871228999de89f0a7fb
Program: sha256:004d37dbfaeb7827e45e7e6686114881b0ef483cc75de8174c82cd6be742e40c
Producer: bbeee997a8ef11816d14fc7a3d2f7e3afb74ceed923c614dafeaf6d92dcc9275